Why most plans fail: the enemies of planning

A plan can look perfect on paper and still go nowhere. Here is why that happens, and what to settle before, during and after you write one.

Every January, millions of people write down what they will do differently this year. By December most of those lists are forgotten. Dr. Faith Obafemi opens her book with exactly this: "We make new year resolutions every year but end each year not fulfilling 50% of them." Her answer to why is one line: a beautiful plan does not equal a successful plan.

That line is worth sitting with. Most of us were taught that the hard part is deciding what we want. Once it is written down neatly, we assume the rest will follow. It rarely does. The plan was never the problem. What happens to the plan is.

A plan is a tool, not a trophy

A wish says what you would like. A plan says what you will do, by when, with what, and what you will do when something gets in the way. The difference sounds small, and it decides almost everything.

"Get fit this year" is a wish. "Walk for 30 minutes before work on Monday, Wednesday and Friday, and if it rains, use the stairs in my building" is a plan. You can check the second one at the end of any week and know whether you kept it.

A plan is also not a mood. Many plans are written on a good day, full of energy, and then asked to work on ordinary days when energy is low. A plan that only works when you feel motivated is not finished yet.

The enemies are usually ordinary

In Effective Planning and Execution, Dr. Faith names seventeen enemies of planning and shows how to overcome each one. This article does not reproduce her list. It looks at a handful of patterns that show up again and again when plans stall, so you can spot them in your own.

  • No real reason. If you cannot say in one sentence why the goal matters to you, it will lose to whatever feels urgent this afternoon.
  • A goal too vague to act on. "Grow my business" gives you nothing to do on Tuesday morning. A plan needs a next action you could start in the next ten minutes.
  • Too many goals at once. Ten priorities is the same as none. Each new goal takes time and attention from the others.
  • No time attached. If a task has no place in your week, your week will fill up without it.
  • Waiting for the right moment. Conditions are rarely perfect. Waiting for them is often fear dressed up as good sense.
  • Not counting what it will cost. Money, hours, energy, help from other people. A plan that ignores its costs collapses the first time one comes due.
  • No review. Plans drift. Without a regular moment to check progress, you find out in December.
  • Quitting after the first slip. Missing one day is normal. Treating one missed day as proof that the plan has failed is what ends most plans.

Notice that none of these is about intelligence or talent. They are habits of thinking, and habits can be changed.

What to settle before you plan

Her book spends time on what to establish before you plan at all, and it is the part most people skip. Before you write a single step, get clear on four things.

Your purpose. Why this goal, and why now? A plan pointed at something you actually care about survives far more setbacks than one you think you should want.

Where you are today. Be honest about your starting point: your time, your money, your skills, your health, the people around you. Plans built on an imaginary starting point fail on contact with the real one.

What you have to work with. List your resources, and the gaps. A gap is not a reason to stop. It becomes one of the first steps in the plan.

What done looks like. Decide how you will know you have finished. Without a finish line, you can work hard for a year and still feel you have achieved nothing.

Write a plan that survives a bad week

Here is a simple way to turn a goal into a plan that holds up in ordinary life.

  1. Pick one outcome for the next 90 days. One. Write it as something you could show someone.
  2. Break it into three to five milestones, each with a date.
  3. Choose the next action for the first milestone, and put it in your calendar as an appointment with yourself.
  4. Name your likely obstacles and decide in advance what you will do about each. "If I miss a morning, I do it at lunch." "If the money runs short, I pause the course, not the practice."
  5. Set a weekly review. Fifteen minutes, same time each week. What did I do, what got in the way, what is next?
  6. Tell one person. Someone who will ask how it is going. Plans kept in private are easier to abandon quietly.

Execution is its own skill

The title of her book puts planning and execution side by side for a reason. Writing the plan is one skill. Carrying it out week after week, when it is boring and nobody is watching, is another. Most people practise the first and hope for the second.

The good news is that execution can be practised in small pieces. Keep one promise to yourself this week. Then another next week. Confidence in your own plans is built the same way as trust in another person: by seeing them follow through.

If you want to see the full list of seventeen enemies and how to beat each one, they are in her book, Effective Planning and Execution. And if you would like help turning your own goal into a plan you will actually keep, you can book a one-to-one planning session with her.

Written with Dr. Faith Obafemi's planning method from Effective Planning and Execution